The Raiders Took a QB First Overall and Then Did the Smartest Thing Possible: Nothing

THURSDAY, OCTOBER 8, 2026

The Raiders took a quarterback first overall in the draft and then did the smartest thing possible: nothing. Four weeks into the NFL season, Fernando Mendoza — the Heisman winner out of Indiana, the No. 1 overall pick in 2026, the kid this entire season was supposedly about — hasn’t played a single down, holding a clipboard while 38-year-old Kirk Cousins runs the offense. And honestly? Doing nothing might be genius.

The report cardThe grade is N/A, and that’s the point

theScore dropped its rookie report card on Oct. 7 — one month into the season, grades for every first-rounder — and for Fernando Mendoza, there was no letter to give. N/A. Incomplete. Not applicable. The No. 1 overall pick hasn’t taken a single regular-season snap, sitting behind Kirk Cousins, 38 years old and in his 15th NFL season, who simply hasn’t given the job back.

Put some history on that: Mendoza is the first No. 1 overall quarterback to not start Week 1 since Baker Mayfield in 2018. Think about how that usually goes. The last decade of No. 1 quarterbacks — Kyler Murray, Joe Burrow, Trevor Lawrence, Bryce Young, Caleb Williams, Cam Ward — all got thrown in immediately, Day 1, no net. The league’s default setting is to hand the keys to the kid and hope the car doesn’t end up in a ditch. The Raiders looked at that tradition and said no.

The campCousins earned it, and Mendoza knew it

None of this happened by accident. In August, coach Kubiak made it official: Cousins was the Week 1 starter, and he “earned it” with a strong camp. That’s coach-speak for the veteran outplayed the rookie, and we’re not pretending otherwise. In a town that loves a coronation, the Raiders chose honesty instead — and the kid took it like a pro.

Mendoza’s own words on it, via theSpun back in August: “I’m excited to see my guys go out there and play and try to be the best teammate possible.” That’s either the most media-trained sentence ever spoken or a genuinely mature read of the situation from a 22-year-old. Given everything we’ve seen from Mendoza since draft night, it reads like the real thing. He’s not pouting. He’s not leaking frustration to reporters. He’s being the best teammate possible while the team wins.

And his preseason wasn’t a disaster that forced their hand, either. Against Arizona, Mendoza went 10-of-16 for 96 yards and a touchdown to Jack Bech, and NFL.com’s Chad Reuter graded the outing a B+ — “put the NFL on notice,” as Touchdown Wire put it. The tools are there. The arm is live. The Raiders just decided the tools could marinate for a while.

The record4-0 is the best quarterback coach alive

Here’s why nobody’s panicking, and why this might be the most quietly brilliant thing the Raiders have done in a decade: they’re 4-0. The 30-27 win over the Chiefs in Week 4 wasn’t just a win — it was the kind of win that buys a coaching staff the benefit of every doubt. When you’re undefeated and your veteran quarterback is dealing, there is no constituency for the rookie. The fans are happy. The locker room is happy. The front office is very, very happy.

Think about how the alternative usually plays out in this league. Team drafts a quarterback first overall. Team stinks. Fan base demands the kid by October. Coach, coaching for his job, throws him in behind a bad line with no run game, the kid gets shell-shocked, and three years later everyone agrees he was “never that good” — when really he was never given a chance. The Raiders skipped every step of that. Cousins wins, Mendoza watches, the line gels, the scheme settles, and the kid’s first start — whenever it comes — happens with a real team around him instead of a demolition site.

The leagueThrowing them to the wolves, reconsidered

The NFL has a quarterback development problem and everybody knows it. Young passers get drafted into hopeless situations, get destroyed behind terrible protection, and get labeled busts before they can legally rent a car. The few who survive — your Mahomeses, your Allens, your Hurts — almost always had something the busts didn’t: time, or a veteran ahead of them, or an organization stable enough to let them grow. Sitting is not a punishment. It’s a strategy, and it’s one the league’s best franchises have used on purpose.

Mendoza’s situation is the ideal version of that strategy, because it’s involuntary in the best way. Nobody staged this as a master plan — Cousins just played well enough that Kubiak had no reason to change anything, and the 4-0 record made the decision for everyone. But the effect is the same as the deliberate redshirt years: the rookie gets NFL meeting rooms, NFL practices, NFL road trips, and zero hits. When his number gets called — Week 8, Week 12, next season, whenever — he’ll know the playbook cold and the locker room will already be his. Sunday’s Patriots matchup is next on the docket, and every Cousins win is another week of free development for Mendoza.